We detected you haven’t selected to personalise the site.


Please select a preference

Matt Wrack General Secretary TUC 2025 BANNER 2.jpg

In an article written for the PoliticsHome website, NASUWT General Secretary Matt Wrack argues that creating opportunity means investing in jobs, communities and public services, not introducing more accountability measures for schools.

After much hype and expectation, the Milburn Review is here. This is a moment that could have been the start of a wider debate about the kind of economy we want and how we create new meaningful jobs in a world of insecure, often low-wage work and all too often, of no jobs at all.

In education much of the debate since the review was published has been the suggestion there should be a “ready for work” standard inspected by Ofsted.

But schools do exactly this already - these are not new priorities that somehow teachers and school leaders did not think about until a former Health Secretary last in government 20 years ago pointed it out to them.

Milburn is proposing to impose another inspection measure leading to more judgements being made about schools and teaching.

How does an Ofsted inspector determine whether a teenager is "ready for work"?  How can schools be fairly judged against a standard shaped by factors far beyond their control?

With schools facing severe staff recruitment and retention challenges, rising levels of pupil need, growing mental health concerns and an increasingly stretched SEND system, the last thing teachers need is yet another accountability framework.

Schools risk being judged on outcomes they do not control with implications for budgets already stripped bare. A young person's future after leaving school is shaped primarily by the local economy, the availability of local jobs, apprenticeships and transport links. These are factors entirely outside the control of schools and of teachers; a point Milburn seems to miss.

Schools may find themselves devoting scarce staff time and resources to meeting new measures linked to factors outside their control. There is a real danger that schools serving disadvantaged communities will be unfairly penalised because of this.

Teachers can’t provide affordable housing or fix our creaking transport infrastructure, they can’t create those jobs in our communities that have been ravaged by de-industrialisation and the failure to invest over decades. These are issues Andy Burnham has claimed to recognise but Milburn’s review does not attempt to address them.

Education is also about much more than simply how employable young people are. It’s about helping young people discover who they are and nurturing their passions and talents.

Teachers help pupils understand the world around them, develop critical thinking and show them how they can become better-informed citizens. If politicians and others try to reduce education to a list of outcomes aimed at employability (as defined by local employers) then that broader purpose of education is diminished.

The real question is not whether schools are doing enough to make young people work-ready, it is whether successive governments have done enough to create decent jobs, apprenticeships and training opportunities.

Too often, debates about economic inactivity focus on the supposed shortcomings of young people themselves rather than the shortcomings of our economy and the failure of politicians.

This review feels like a missed opportunity. Our country faces massive challenges that require bold political ambition and serious investment.

We need to build hundreds of thousands of affordable houses and retrofit millions of homes and public buildings to improve energy efficiency.

We need investment in renewable energy, modern transport networks and updating our critical national infrastructure. Our long-term industrial strategy should nurture advanced manufacturing and engineering, as well as supporting emerging technologies of the future.

Not only that but we should also recognise the enormous potential of the creative industries which are one of Britain's great strengths and a source of high-skilled, high-value employment.

Too often these sectors are treated as an afterthought in economic policy, despite their capacity to generate economic growth and provide rewarding careers for young people with a wide range of talents and interests.

We also need investment in the wider social fabric that underpins the lives of young people and of the wider community.

Affordable housing, accessible healthcare, mental health support and reliable public transport all help determine whether a young person can access education, training or employment.

If we are serious about improving young people's life chances, we must stop looking for solutions that place ever-greater burdens on schools and teachers. We need a strategy that creates opportunity and invests in communities, ‘in every postcode’, as the Prime Minister has said.

We reject any approach based on welfare cuts or the blaming of schools and teachers.

Young people should not be penalised for the failure of successive governments to create decent jobs, training opportunities and the conditions in which they can thrive and feel hope for the future.

That is the challenge we should be focused on meeting. And that is the opportunity that the Milburn Review has largely missed.
 

OK

Please confirm

Please login

Please login

To use this feature you need to be logged in, please login now to continue